There are two options to terminate an employment contract based on disciplinary or performance grounds.:

  • Through court proceedings: The court is requested to terminate the employment contract;

  • By mutual consent: Both parties enter into a settlement agreement (mutual termination agreement).

In the event of termination based on disciplinary or performance grounds, we usually need to involve the legal counsel.

The following requirements may justify a dismissal:

Underperformance

To terminate the employment contract based on underperformance, the employer must be able to substantiate that:

  • The employee’s performance is unsatisfactory;

  • The unsatisfactory performance is not caused by illness or defects of the employee;

  • The employee is informed timely about the unsatisfactory performance;

  • The employee has had enough opportunities and time to improve the performance and

  • The unsatisfactory performance is not a result of a lack of care of the employer in relation to education or working conditions.

Additionally, the employer should be able to substantiate that there is no other suitable position available for the employee.

It follows from case law that an employee should, in principle, have completed a performance improvement plan (PIP) before a court will terminate the employment contract based on underperformance. The length of the employment relationship, in principle, affects the length of a PIP. As a rule of thumb, the length of the performance plan generally varies between 6 – 12 months.

Culpable behavior and omissions

To terminate the employment contract based on culpable behavior or omission of the employee, the employer should be able to substantiate that the employee has behaved culpably in such a way that it cannot reasonably be required from the employer to continue the employment contract. This means that the employee’s behavior should qualify as culpable.

Disrupted employment relationship

To terminate the employment contract based on a disrupted employment relationship, the employer should be able to substantiate that the working relationship is seriously and durable damaged in such a way that they cannot reasonably be required to continue the employment contract. Additionally, the employer should be able to substantiate that there is no other suitable position available for the employee.

Both parties, i.e., the employer and the employee, should experience a seriously damaged working relationship. If the employee does not acknowledge that the working relationship is damaged, the risk applies that the court will not terminate the employment contract.

Did we answer your query?